Breaking News
More () »

Their dinner theater play set an endurance record. Now, 'I do, I do' couple marks 50 years of marriage

David Anders and Susan Geoppinger extended a six-week run of "I do, I do" at the Chanhassen Dinner Theatre to 22 1/2 years.

CHANHASSEN, Minn. — As actors, they set a record that may never be broken.

But Susan Goeppinger and David Anders just reached another mark of which they are equally proud.

“We didn’t think we’d make it 50 years, really,” David says.

In July, David and Susan returned to Chanhassen Dinner Theatres to celebrate 50 years of marriage.

Family and friends gathered beneath the same roof under which the actors fell in love during the early 1970s, before going on to set an endurance record that stands to this day.

Credit: Chad Nelson/KARE 11
Susan Goeppinger and David Anders with a portrait of their family.

From February of 1971 until June of 1993, David and Susan performed the musical “I do, I do” 7,645 times.

Their streak of 22-and-half-years still represents the longest-running professional theater production with the original cast in history.

“We had a group of kids come from their high school,” Susan says, “and I realized during the show that they were born the year we started.”

Some 700,000 people saw the show during its run at Chanhassen.

Three governors – Wendall Anderson, Al Quie and Arnie Carlson – issued proclamations saluting the couple as David and Susan extended their streak. 

They posed with Mary Martin, who played the female lead in “I do, I do” on Broadway. 

They appeared on NBC’s Today Show and in People magazine.

Not bad for a play initially scheduled for six weeks.

“They became as much of the story as the show itself,” says Gary Gisselman, who cast David and Susan in the musical. “They were kind of their own publicity, in a way.”

Credit: Michael Paul, Act One, Too Photography
Chanhassen Dinner Theatre publicity still of David Anders and Susan Goeppinger in “I do, I do.”

“I do, I do,” follows newlyweds Agnes and Michael through 50 years of their marriage.

When cast in the role of Michael, David had been part of the company at Chanhassen for three years, recruited by Gary from a theater in Omaha.

Susan had been acting in New York, before Gary flew in on a recruiting trip and hired her too.  

“I think a lot of the reason that the show was so successful is that they were so successful and their affection for each other is so genuine,” the veteran Twin Cities director says.

David and Susan began to have feelings for each other not long after the show went into production.

“It was really a professional chemistry more than anything, and then we became friends, and then, finally, as time went by, it just blossomed,” David says.

Besides, he adds with a laugh, “’I do, I do,’ of course, is all about marriage and a bedroom and all that sort of thing. You can't go to bed with a woman that many times without getting attached to her.”

Life continued to imitate art as David and Susan had two children – a boy and a girl – just like the characters they played.

Credit: Anders family
David Anders and Susan Goeppinger with their children Chris and Erin.

Attending “I do, I do” at Chanhassen became a tradition for married couples, who first arrived as newlyweds and later came to the show with children in tow.

David and Susan recall the night a husband in the audience brought his girlfriend to the show, only to be confronted in the theater by his wife.

“And I said, what kind of idiot takes his girlfriend to see 50 years of marriage,” David says laughing.

After their KARE 11 interview, David and Susan stood near a piano at their old stage, singing songs from “I do, I do.”

They locked eyes as they sang.

Love wasn’t an act for David and Susan, but like all married couples they occasionally argued, sometimes on show days.

“All of a sudden the fights in the show are very crisp,” David says, as both he and Susan share a good laugh.

The 1993 closing of “I do, I do” was covered extensively by Twin Cities media. One headline read “Adieu! Adieu!”

Credit: Chad Nelson/KARE 11
David Anders and Susan Goeppinger return to their old theater to sing songs from the musical “I do, I do,” in which they performed for 22 ½ years.

David and Susan immediately went on to play another married couple, Tevye and Golde, in Chanhassen’s production of Fiddler on Roof.

They continued acting, moved to Phoenix for 10 years, then returned to the Twin Cities where they’ve retired in Edina. 

David is 85 now. Susan is 80.

The couple that was once the toast of the town, now regularly walks in anonymity at Centennial Lakes.

“That was a long time ago,” David says on their stroll.

They are proudest not of their record-setting production, but the son, daughter, and three grandchildren their union produced.

Both their children are active in Twin Cities theater. Chris plays guitar in the pit orchestra at Chanhassen. Erin works for the Guthrie and other local theaters as a sign language interpreter.

As for David and Susan, they’re still glad they said, “I do.”

“We’re still alive, still kicking,” Susan says.

“And happy,” David adds.

Credit: Molly Andresen, Sweet Hearts Photography
David Anders and Susan Geoppinger celebrate their 50th wedding anniversary in front of a publicity still from "I do, I do," the the record-setting theater production in which they starred.

Boyd Huppert is always looking for great stories to share in the Land of 10,000 Stories! Send us your suggestions by filling out this form:


Watch more from the Land of 10,000 Stories:

Watch the latest videos from the Land of 10,000 Stories in our YouTube playlist and subscribe to the Land of 10,000 Stories Complete Collection on YouTube.

Before You Leave, Check This Out